Hoggle’s Attorney Calls for Charges to be Dropped

Catherine Hoggle, the Clarksburg mom accused in the disappearance of her two toddlers, could have all charged against her dropped if the Montgomery County Courts agree with motions to dismiss the case filed by her attorney Tuesday.CatherineHoggle-300x300

Hoggle was arrested September 12 and  faces three misdemeanor charges- detaining a child, neglect of a minor and obstructing and hindering. She is awaiting a mental evaluation by the courts at the Clifton T. Perkins Hospital Center . Family have described Hoggle as being a paranoid schizophrenic. Her two children, Jacob, 2 and Sarah, 3 are still missing.

Rockville attorney David Felsen filed the motions Tuesday in the case claiming that police inappropriately  interrogated Catherine Hoggle Oct. 1 at the Perkins Hospital Center without the presence of her attorney. The motion said that the detectives told Hoggle that they would allow her to hug her children if she told them where they are and the filing also claimed the detectives said they would allow Hoggle to spend time with her third child if she gave the location of Sarah and Jacob.

The filing continued to say that detectives told her “if the children were no longer alive, Catherine Hoggle would be allowed to attend and assist in the preparations of their funerals,” according to the motion.

Felsen said Hoggle’s counsel was not present during the questioning.

The court filing claims the detectives called Hoggle “a monster” during this interrogation and refused to let her speak to her attorney, at one point telling her Felsen was not representing her anymore.

“The motion speaks for itself,” Felsen told MyMCMedia Wednesday, adding that “significant portions of the account has been independently corroborated.”

Ramon Korionoff, spokesman for the Montgomery County Office of the State’s Attorney responded in an email to MyMCMedia’s request for comment saying, “We are reviewing the filing and will reply to Mr. Felsen in due course. At this point we will refrain from commenting as it is a sensitive investigation with many dimensions. We will let our motions in court and in filings speak for themselves.”

A Montgomery County Police spokesman declined comment about the allegations.

In fact Lindsey Hoggle, Catherine’s mother, said she originally hired Felsen’s law firm for her daughter when she was arrested, but “severed the relationship” with Felsen.

“I felt like the representation was not going in the right direction or in the best interest of my daughter which includes us finding the babies,” she told MyMCMedia.

Felsen would not answer whether he is taking the case pro bono.

Lindsey Hoggle said she has tried to visit her daughter at the Jessup hospital center but her daughter refused to see her.

In reaction to the motions in the case, Lindsey Hoggle said she “doesn’t put much credibility in the claims she made to her lawyer,” pointing to her daughter’s alleged altered mental capacity.

“From day one we have dealt with a mix of truths and untruths and conspiracy,” she said. “That is the nature of this illness.”

Hoggle said she may consider applying for legal guardianship of her daughter which would allow her to make medical decisions for her.

“It is something to consider. I am trying to do what is in her best interest and what is in the best interest of the children.




Charges Could Be Dropped for Hoggle, Judge To Make Decision

Catherine Hoggle | File photo

Charges could possibly be dropped for Catherine Hoggle, the mother who was charged with the murder of her two children. Sarah and Jacob Hoggle were last seen with their mother Catherine, before they vanished in 2014. A competency status hearing was held on Tuesday. This comes after Hoggle’s Attorney David Felsen, filed a motion to […]

Read more

Judge Delays Decision on Dismissing Murder Charges Against Hoggle

021820 pic c

The expectation was that the case of Catherine Hoggle — which received local, national and international attention six years ago – would come to a resolution on Tuesday. That did not happen. For the first time, Troy Turner had the opportunity to speak in court. He made it clear that he just wanted justice for […]

Read more

Catherine Hoggle Found Incompetent to Stand Trial Again


A competent status hearing was held on Tuesday to determine if there has been any changes in Catherine Hoggle’s mental condition. The judge found Hoggle incompetent to stand trial for the 2014 disappearance of her two children Sarah and Jacob Hoggle. Montgomery County State’s Attorney John McCarthy says the next status hearing for Hoggle will […]

Read more

State's Attorney Seeks Delay in Hoggle Competency Ruling

photo of Catherine Hoggle for slider

The Montgomery County State’s Attorney’s Office is asking a Circuit Court judge to hold off ruling on Catherine Hoggle’s competency for four more months, according to a motion filed this week. Hoggle, 32, faces murder charges in the deaths of her two children, Sarah and Jacob. She has been ruled incompetent since the children’s disappearance […]

Read more

Catherine Hoggle to be Evaluated by New Psychiatrist

McCarthy Hoggle ftrd

Catherine Hoggle, the mother accused of killing two of her children nearly five years ago, has spent most of the time since then at Clifton Perkins Hospital Center in Jessup, a maximum-security psychiatric hospital. That could change in August. Based on the hospital’s psychiatric evaluations, judges have ruled Hoggle incompetent to stand trial. Montgomery County […]

Read more

Hoggle Again Ruled Incompetent; Prosecutors Seek Independent Evaluation


A Montgomery County judge ruled Tuesday that Catherine Hoggle, who has been accused of killing her two children, remained incompetent to stand trial. The decision was the latest in a series of rulings where Hoggle has been brought before a judge and found unable to assist in her defense based on reports of her doctor […]

Read more

Hoggle Update: Prosecutors Seek Independent Evaluation on Mental Competency

Hoggle search fund out of money for slider 450 x280

It’s been about four years since the disappearance of Sarah, and Jacob Hoggle. They were last seen with their mother, Catherine Hoggle-who has not given any information regarding her children’s whereabouts since their disappearance. Most recently, Catherine Hoggle had a status hearing to determine her current mental status, and if she is competent to stand […]

Read more

Hoggle Again Ruled Incompetent to Stand Trial


Catherine Hoggle was once again ruled incompetent to stand trial on Friday. The woman faces two murder charges in connection with the disappearances of her two children four years ago. The children — Sarah who was then 3 and Jacob who was then 2 — have never been found. They were reported missing, and Catherine […]

Read more

Hoggle Expected in Court Friday


Catherine Hoggle, who faces two murder charges for the disappearance of her two young children, is scheduled to be in court again Friday. Once again, the issue will be whether she is competent to stand trial. She will be appearing before Circuit Court Judge Robert Greenberg. The case had been before Judge Michael Mason; the […]

Read more

Father of Missing Children: 'There Will Never Be Closure'

troy turner 9_2018

It’s been four years since Sarah and Jacob Hoggle went missing.  During a candlelight vigil Friday evening, the children’s father, Troy Turner, said every day is getting harder because there are no signs of their whereabouts. The children were last seen with their mother, Catherine Hoggle, in 2014.  She was recently charged for first degree […]

Read more
Like this post? Sign up for our Daily Update here.
Mitti Hicks

About Mitti Hicks

Mitti Hicks is a multimedia journalist and community engagement specialist with Montgomery Community Media. She is passionate about telling stories that impact our community and may be reached at MHicks@mymcmedia.org and on Twitter @mittimegan.


| Comments are closed.

Engage us on Facebook

Follow us on Twitter